| Class of 2011 |
 |
Brandy Stover - William and Mary |
| |
| Class of 2008 |
 |
Ellie Carrico - Ball State University |
 |
Stacey Rowley - Illinois State University |
| |
| Class of 2005 |
 |
Adrienne Mills - Auburn University |
 |
Sarah Parsons - University of Arizona |
| |
| Class of 2003 |
 |
Whitney Albright - Illinois State University |
 |
Janáe Cox - West Virginia University |
 |
Kelly Eveslage - Northern Illinois University |
 |
Shawntelle Thompson - Kent State University |
| |
| Class of 2001 |
 |
Anna Hunsinger - Michigan State University |
 |
Lauren Newcomb - University of Illinois |
| |
| Class of 1999 |
 |
Mindy Smith - University of Kentucky |
| |
| Class of 1998 |
 |
Whitney Morgan - University of Alabama |